I was using my 2017 Macbook AIR for 3 years. I am able to use it for many hours non-stop
4 months ago I have bought a new 13 inch Macbook Pro. I get the eye strain after 20-30 minutes, though it is not so bad as I had with my Dell XPS 13 (2019). Dell XPS was giving me literal pain in my eyes after 5-6 minutes and i returned it to the shop.
Any ideas about why it is happening?
I am able to use my Ipad 3 gen without problems (yeah, it is really old) but the new iPad (2020) is giving me the eye strain after 20 minutes too.
Looking for people with similar reactions to certain Apple devices
Tom220 Very sorry to hear about your problems.
If I recall correctly, DELL XPS was judged one of the few completely eyestrain-free laptops by more than one user on this forum, at the point that I was considering getting one. Many people cannot instead use MacBooks later than 2015.
My conclusion is that there is no common denominator at all for our visual issues and no one really knows what is going on wrong. The individual may be lucky and skilled to find a good solution for himself, but this is almost never going to apply to another person. It is super demoralizing.
Sorry for sounding this negative. I know I have not answered your question. I guess no one can.
I tried my grandma's iphone 8 max with ios 13 and it is usable, although not as comfortable as my iPhone 6 with ios 10. my girlfriend's iphone xs with ios 13 was unusable, usable with ios 14. now i try to update the iphone 8. are there any differences between ios 14 and 14.2?
You can use iPad min 5? That's great! I would love to be able to use a tablet. I tried it previously and it was no good. Maybe I had a bad panel. What iOS version are you on?
[deleted]
- Edited
New iphone 11 user here. I'd like to share my experience after 4 days.
Edit: Face ID was not the reason. I turned it off but nothing has improved. It is definitely the screen. iPhone 11 screen causes significant eye strain just like my laptop (before I disable temporal dithering on that laptop), so maybe it is also a dithering technology applied to the iPhone screen as the root cause here.
(So my eyes have a thing with PWM and dithering and I struggled when buying laptop. I managed to settle down with an HP laptop that does not have PWM, and uninstalled the Intel driver to get rid of the dithering thing).
I have iPad 6th generation and all is fine, I watch movies, reading, playing games for hours without problem at all. However, recently I reset the iPad (all settings and data) and suddenly I can’t watch the iPad for more than 10 minutes without getting this weird pressure on my forehead and my eyes. So I tried my brother’s iPad with the same gen, totally fine. So I am guessing it had to do with the software I guess. Another comment I read when people update to macOS Big Sur on Mac also cause this kind of pressure and headache. It’s like there is something on the screen but we can’t see it. Anyway I have reported to Apple through their feedback and hope others do too because this problem is annoying and sadly I can’t use my iPad anymore
I had the same issue on MBP 13" 2017 and on my current MBP 16" 2019. Screens are ok, all you need to do is to reset SMC and NVRAM. And do it several times ! I succeed only after 5th try and only when my battery was discharged.
- Edited
Thank you so much for posting this; it's both terrible and also encouraging to see there are many others experiencing the same. I can tell you this:
The X & XR & 12 phones all made me sick.
The 11 (running the latest iOS) is less bad than OLED, but still bad.
The 2022 SE is better than the 11 but I still get a weird pale orange "afterglow" tint when I look away from the screen & it doesn't feel good to look at the screen. It's also running the latest iOS and has the 13 chip.
My eyes LOVE the 6s that I haven't upgraded the iOS on at ALL. It's running 13.1.2.
But my time is running out, since this iOS is starting to not be supported by apps.
The next tech after OLED is "mini LEDs" but if what the OP suspects about the processors are true, then these might also cause huge problems and make us sick. LED lighting in general makes me feel gross in rooms etc. It's so "shrill" on my eyes if that makes sense.
My optometrist says I "have pupils that let in more light than normal." So there. Maybe yours do too. I have perfect 20/20 vision and I'm an interior designer & graphic designer who happily stares at her old MSI laptop & her 6S phone all day and night. But I'm ABSOLUTELY TERRIFIED to realize that I may not soon be able to have tools to design and work any longer, or to communicate with people like the rest of society, because Apple keeps releasing products that are not healthy for me.
At some point (basically now) we have to form a group and make a huge effort to start a dialogue with Apple. If Apple can create a line of products for those of us whose eyes need gentler products, then they'd know they'd have ALL of the market from us and can charge us a fortune or whatever they like, because we literally have no other products to turn to. For them, that's not a bad thing. All they have to do is use old tech.
Having a group on facebook might even be useful. Seeing there are real people behind the words might help Apple realize it's worth helping out.
studioceleste Producers like Dell, LG etc imo aknowledge our issues and produce wonderful screens year after year, dell business line to my limited experience is particularly good in this matter.
I am exactly like you with my symptoms, and I can use the iphone 8 just fine, so maybe you can "upgrade" to that to be ok for a few more years? There is plenty of usable android out there with decent specs as well.
Maybe we will not be able to use the flagships, but I am quite confident that there will always be options for us
I would however not bet on apple providing gentler products. Their business strategy is to sell as few products to as many costumers as possible, we are clearly not a sufficiently large group
studioceleste At some point (basically now) we have to form a group and make a huge effort to start a dialogue with Apple. If Apple can create a line of products for those of us whose eyes need gentler products, then they'd know they'd have ALL of the market from us and can charge us a fortune or whatever they like, because we literally have no other products to turn to. For them, that's not a bad thing. All they have to do is use old tech.
I don't think its entirely a problem of tech companies "not caring" but when there's a vague concern of "eye strain" that has many potential causes where some could be a preexisting medical issue being provoked by unknown properties of a display or even its input source and there's otherwise no clear "cause and effect" here, can you really blame people at "big tech companies" simply throwing their hands up and giving up "solving" this issue under these conditions?
I don't.
Thank you for your reply.
I hadn't realized there were still desktop screens that will work for people with LED sensitivities! I'll be sure to delve into the threads to see which ones do when I need to buy new. That is a great relief to hear. I'm glad these companies actually understand.
The iphone 8 you'd suggest trying.
Well, I guess it's worth trying a used one but I guess I've got a $250 paperweight if it doesn't since I'd be the only weirdo trying to buy one these days.
The original poster mentioned he suspects it could have to do with either the chip or the iOS that's the culprit on LCD screens. Out of curiosity Can you please tell me what iOS you're running?
Apple hasn't set itself up as a company to be approachable, to be sure. I also wonder if feedback doesn't reach their teams in a way that's effective. Well, I'm not done with them yet-- I may try sending physical paper letters and trying to get in touch with a real human who is slightly higher up. I've recently seen a few youtubers also talking about OLED being awful for them so it would seem there are a few of us out there.
Cheers.
I don't know.
Never having tried to approach them in a concrete way before, I'd rather imagine my efforts to be successful and not failing, otherwise I'll never try.
I've only really glanced at the posts in the intro page, but it would appear as if the commonalities are:
-LED averse/sensitive
-pulse modulation sensitive
-and identifying if it's the chip or the drivers causing further issues, and why.
But sure, if money is the only motivator for them, no I can't see them trialing different approaches and sending prototypes out to a few of us. But I don't know, I'd rather think we stand a chance of remaining in modern society instead of imagining we can't use smartphones in the next 5 years.
- Edited
studioceleste For what I gathered during the years reading blog and articles, Apple is fully aware of the effects that for example PWM has on some people. They will never aknowledge till it is fully solved technologically, and even then, I fear that might not actually happen. Why would the aknwoledge something potentially bad from a brand point of view?
https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-iphone-12-mini-makes-me-sick-literally
Is anybody doing real research into the problem, in terms of how many people are affected and how to prevent it?
The Chinese government may be, it is very concerned about their children’s eye development because they spend too many hours in front of displays, and they have set some requirements for displays
I don't think it is a coincidence that many chinese producers offer dc dimming and market "easier to the eyes" products.
As per iphone 8, I have always had it with the latest iOS, now it is on iOS 16. (Like you, I cannot use latest iphone SE or iphone 11)
I've been using all types of mac computers, phones and tablets since around 2005 with absolutely no issues. I'm a technology trainer who teaches software and stares at PCs, Macs, and HDTV's all day. In 2017 I purchased an iMac Pro and from the moment the apple logo over black came on during boot up, it immediately hurt by eyes. I put the machine aside for about a year. I then decided to play with it again and went through numerous trouble shooting phases including SwitchResX, Ram and other PRAM resets, FLux, ect. When rebooting, one time it came up and the problem was completely gone. So something I did took it out of the mode that was causing my severe eye strain. Problem is, I don't know what I did to fix it because I was trying multiple solutions one after another. And it was well over a year ago. Worked with it no issues at all for 1.5 years. Recently went into the Display settings, held OPTION down so when I hit the SCALED button it would reveal exact resolution setting, and it INSTANTLY change the display settings to bring the EYE PAIN back immediately. The only thing I saw change was that the fonts got crisper (more detailed) and the color saturation increased. The size of the fonts did not change. And I can't get it to go away again.
In 2019 I purchased a 13" MacBook Pro. No eye issues at all. Then, after causing the iMac Pro display to return to causing eye strain, the 2019 MacBook pro also starting causing me eye strain issues. I didn't change any settings on it. Someone suggested because I've got my accounts syncing to the cloud, the display settings from the iMac Pro migrated to the 2019 MacBook Pro. I don't know if I buy that or not. I did upgrade the OS on both machines months ago and there was no eye strain related to that. I worked on them both successfully for months after. My gut tells me that there was a configuration in the older OS that I was able to manipulate to remove the issue causing the eye strain, and that config was retained even though I upgraded the OS. But when I went into the iMac's Display setings and hit OPTION + SCALE, it caused it to overide the previous OS config and click into the newest OS display settings. I can't prove this, but it feels like this might be it. I can't explain why the MacBook Pro would all of a sudden start causing me problems.
By the way, I'm also putting both the iMac Pro and MacBook Pro through non-Retina HD-only external monitors to eliminate the possibility of it being a problem with my looking at the built-in Retina displays on those machines. Didn't help.
All of a sudden, my iPhone 12 Pro Max is also causing me eye strain. Never did that before.
I suspect spending all day working on these machines is causing eye fatigue which is making it more difficult for me to look at any computer screens. Even my HDTV has slowly started causing eye strain, but not as severe. I have found that turning all the displays complete black and white has halved the eye strain. Doesn't entirely eliminate it, but it does allow me to not have to pop Extra Strength Tylenols for headaches.
Eye doctor says nothing is wrong with my eyes. I have been using readers for computer work for years, just for focus assistance. We're now trying some prescription glasses with various blue light and other options to see if this will help at all. I will get them later this week and report back.
To see if this was only Mac-related, I picked up an inexpensive Windows Laptop and worked on that for a week. It was alot less eye strain, but still there.
- Edited
brvideo I changed my room lighting to a 40W "warm/milky?" incandescent a few days ago and it feels better than the LED tubelight I had earlier (which wasn't too bad even if a bit too bright), and also the "daylight" CFL and the small flickerless LED tube I tried for a few days each before the incandescent. A change in lighting might ease the strain from the monitors a bit (it might take a couple of days to really feel the difference). The amplitude of the flicker from incandescents and cfls is (generally) less than that of LEDs with flicker I think, and also their colour spectrum might be easier on our eyes methinks coz I found the flickerless LED a bit harsh even though it was just 5W … but I need to go back and try it again to be sure.
- Edited
I'm not using any electronic lighting in my home office where I've been working for the last two years. And nothing has changed. There is a cathedral ceiling with a window behind me that lets some sunlight in. Most of the wall is behind closed vertical blinds but there is some light coming from the very top. But I don't think that's a cause. If it's raining and really dark I do have a desk lamp but I rarely turn it on except maybe at night and that's not when I'm working.
I have played with patching one eye just to see what happens, and yes, there is a great deal less pain. But, I can't work like that for any length of time nor would I even want to try and adapt to it. I did mention this to my eye doctor and asked if this means I have "binocular vision" or some similar ailment. He said everybody uses both eyes to create images and sometimes there are differences in perception but nothing is wrong with my eyes in that regard.
francerex
Thanks for letting me know you're running the latest iOS on the 8 and that it's still fine for your eyes. I'll start digging around to find a used 8 with decent storage and hang tight until they introduce phones that don't make me sick.
Interesting about Apple, but if they do remedy it they'll just introduce the new tech with fancy marketing words so that people won't even realize it's less harmful for their eyes. Let's hope it makes it to a stage to be remedied!
- Edited
I have the same symptoms as you described with the same devices.
However I can use iPhone 11, XR e SE just fine (LCD ones).
To my surprise I can not use the new MacBook pros nor the new studio display.
I use to work at Apple as a software engineer and I’ve raise this concern with the display team which tried their best to understand what was wrong with me/the screens, the guess is the PWM but it is still unknown since the XDR displays (new iPad 11 inch, MacBooks and studio display) have much higher frequency than iphone oled displays and I still can’t use it.