Glad to be here, guys. Sharing your fate, can't use any modern LED displays as they are all equally intolerable and have the same noxious effect on me. I have switched 4 monitors in the past couple of years and it wasn't easy for me. I had to buy and sell them every time, some of you should know how tiresome that can be and I think this is pretty much the end of the line for me. Now I'm targetting a really old monitor, preferably CCFL-backlit one. Of course, I'd rather it was new and boxed and I would probably pay over $200 for one, but if I don't find one like that I will just have to settle for a used and cheaper one. C'est la vie.
The monitors I've tried:
- HP Z23i (IPS, 1080p, 60hz, PWM, 250cd/m2, 2013)
- ViewSonic VG2719 (IPS/ADS, 1080p, 75hz, flicker-free, 300cd/m2 2020)
- Asus MG248QR (TN+Film, 1080p, 144hz, flicker-free, 350cd/m2, 2016)
- NEC E221N (AH-IPS, 1080p, 60hz, flicker-free, 250cd/m2, 2017)
All of these are equally unbearable. I've tried everything, can't even bother writing the full report, because none of it really matters. It's positively something in the backlight or temporal dithering/FRC or whatever. I don't care to find out anymore, because whatever it is we can't fix it anyway. I just want a normal thing for Christ sake.
At first I thought it's an issue specific to IPS technology as a lot of people seem to complain about it, but it's not true. I believe the reason people tend to assume that is because at some point they move from their older TN CCFL- or early type LED-backlit panels to newer ones, which are mostly IPS these days, and naturally conclude it must be it. Wrong, and I have personally confirmed it. You may have noticed a TN monitor on my list. Believe it or not, I got it specifically to get rid of the eye-strain while sacrificing some of the advantages of IPS. Waste of time, folks. It was the same exact thing. Same. Exact. Thing.
The actual symptoms. In about 5-10 minutes I begin to feel some pressure in my eyes, like I can't relax them for a second and little by little my temple-side ocular muscles get strained more and more. Basically, the longer I look at it, the worse it gets. I'm pretty sure at some point my eyes would simply explode if I tried to soldier through it, which I never did, simply because it gets bad enough much sooner. I also get this tinkling sensation in my forehead, yawny and drowsy feeling as well as mild nausea.
The only displays that don't currently bother me is my laptop screen (HP ZBook 15 G2), which is probably one of the worst TN panels with regards to color and viewing angles, and a couple of really ancient CCFL-type 4:3 displays - LG Flatron L1952S and L1753TR. These don't give me any problems whatsoever, which lead me to conclude that I should be specifically looking for something old enough to be sure the problem isn't there. I think anything between 2008 and 2010 should be good. I got my eye on NEC MultiSync EA231WMI, an all-round decent IPS monitor, which did really well back in the day and if I ever get a chance it's going to be my ultimate purchase. I just have a hunch that all my problems will end right there. The only downside to it is that it's a little more power hungry, but I'd much rather it consumed more power than my eyes and sanity.
By the way, I do confirm that most of these displays are warm and kind of toxic to look at, it feels like there's just too much red and green in them, while blue seems to be consumed by reds and greens and appear somewhat indistinct and washed out, BUT… the latest monitor I got (NEC E221N) is different. It's pretty cold by default and has overall decent blues. Colors are not oversaturated, they're just normal. Frankly, it feels more like a level-upped TN-Film panel, than your typical IPS. Sadly, that too doesn't help the strain.
Regarding my vision, it's not perfect anymore, my eyes see differently now, I also have hypermetropia, but it doesn't explain why I don't get issues with this older type of displays, so going "check your eyes" would be definitely irrelevant here.
Hope this is a useful input.