Now that we have no PWM on MBA M2 what to do with FRC/Dithering?
MAS-76 Did you face similar issue for M1 Macbook Air as well. And also why changing to sRGB would not help? Wouldn’t that make the display 8bit without dithering atleast for Macbook Air M2
I had the same issue with the M1 MacBook Air. Changing to sRGB did not work. Nor did SwitchResX on the older 2019 Intel machine (setting to millions of colors). Nothing has worked so far for any machine post 2015
The latest review on notebookcheck confirms that there are no temporal dithering on M2 air
Just picked one of these up today, I'll definitely post again with impressions on eye strain.
Really interesting that there's no sign of dithering or PWM, I wonder if Apple is noticing more users complaining about these problems.
- Edited
the123blackjack bookcheck confirms that there are no temporal dithering on M2 air
From this Notebookcheck link:
So, we examined the IPS panel of the Air M2 with a microscope and created a slow-motion recording with 240 images per second. While we were able to detect temporal dithering, for example, in the current MacBook Pro 16 with the Mini-LED panel in some particular gray color tones, this was neither the case in the old MacBook Air M1 nor in the new MacBook Air M2
Looks like they couldn't detect dithering in M1 either?
Found this thread on MacRumors.
ryans Yeah i am also the OP of that thread .. So the test done by notebookcheck conclusive or flawed?
with the looks of it M2 air is the best eye care macbook that we can buy
- No PWM
- No Temporal Dithering
- Edited
MAS-76 There is an option to disable dithering, at least, for the integrated card. I already did it for my laptop and it really disables dithering. The PWM effect still remains. But it is, of course, much better than having the PWM + dithering screen.
I will share how to disable dithering on the Intel card soon.
- Edited
MAS-76 That's weird that you still feel eye strain. According to notebookcheck, MBA M2 doesn't have dithering but I tend to believe that human eye feels dithering better than their tests.
Probably, they used 240 FPS camera to detect dithering but it can only be caught by 3000 FPS camera.
How can it not have dithering? Is it a 10 bit panel? I kind of doubt it? But maybe?
- Edited
the123blackjack So the test done by notebookcheck conclusive or flawed?
By this video, I am thinking flawed
Moe3224 I’m just wondering if there’s a fix for it.
I wish there was. It is worth getting your eyes properly checked.
ryans You won't believe what's happening with me, I use windows laptop for work that is connected to two external monitors and I use an iPad Pro 11" all day too with no issues. When I connect my MBA m1 to my monitors after 30mins my eyes get really red and itchy, I can't focus on the screen when looking at text.
@Moe3224 I have the same. I dont use Mac, but I have 2 windows computers that are OK, but have tried several which, when I connect to the same monitor, are not fine and my eyes go bloodshot in few hours. It is not the same as with PWM, a bit slower irritation, but if I use several days, my eyes are totally bloodshot and colleagues ask if I have been crying or have a hangover.
Yes, recently this has been the case. Previously I was only sensitive to PWM and most modern laptop screens, but now they have made some changes to the software, so that the irritation comes through even with a display that is fine with other computers
I've been using the M2 Air for about a week now, it's definitely easier on the eyes in my experience. I still get a little dizzy after prolonged use, but it doesn't cause the gritty eyes, migraine, lingering pain above the eyes, etc. I'm actually planning on selling my M1 and just keeping the M2.
My setup is:
- sRGB Color Profile
- True Tone On
- Auto-Brightness Off
- Usually kept at 50% brightness
I'd definitely recommend trying this one out if the M1 gave you trouble