Hi,
Has anyone tried to enable beta downloads and try MAC OS Sequoia? I have hope that apple will have some changes applied which incorporates feedback on eye strain they have received so far (direct channels, forums, etc.). I personally kind of thinking of installing it, but maybe someone already did it, this would save some time.
Donux I hate the bearer of bad news, but unless someone involved with engineering at these "big tech companies" (not necessarily just Apple) either experiences issues themselves, or some combination of them being really bored (joke) or we have empirical "evidence" what could be wrong along with the internal connections to get the evidence in front of "the right people" (and not another customer service drone) I'm not optimistic for change in the right direction
Donux As someone else here once said regarding correlating positive reviews from "normal" people with reduced probability of a product causing eyestrain, and I feel a similar concept applies here as well.
All of those quotes from people you're quoting with VA panels espousing their virtues are not people who experience the types of severe debilitating eye strain discussed in these forums. Their perspectives are nice and all, and may hint at potential options, but really bear little relevance to us as a group.
That is to say if you really think these issues are going to be solved by virtue of engineers using the same technology they develop. I think you are mistaken. If that was true Samsung would not try to justify in continuing to utilize PWM flicker in their OLED displays of which they are the primary supplier for the industry, Apple would not be regressing eye comfort with miniLED, etc. That is to say not that change is impossible but barring the above caveats it's unlikely to come from the engineers themselves.
JTL Good point. But I still refuse to internalize learned hopelessness, I like macs a lot, and some solution will be found I believe - either external or software based. Also, just to make sure we are not stuck in constant complaining, I have contacted notebookcheck.com to ask if they could share some more details about temporal dithering testing. Even without finding a solution, just good product testing would be enough. The big confusion now is - people read reviews and think that device A and device B are absolutely fine only to find that it is not. This can make someone really mad. So testing is too poor and could be improved.
Anyone did update already ? I know it is available for me, but I did not update yet. I am interested to know if it gets better or worse.
JTL I agree that these issues won't be solved by engineers at most companies.
I think that a company needs to view this as a niche, a profitable niche, with an option for growth.
And a small company is better, because this niche would be more meaningful for them.
And it needs to require the minimal amount of work/change/risk from that company.
And maybe, once this exists from a smaller company, and becomes somewhat popular, it would convince bigger companies to add that too.
What do you think ?
autobot Someone in the other posts mentioned new parameters introduced in the Sequoia related to display/rendering, also there are new UI features to reduce potential causes. Something is clearly happening, at least that is how I see it. Also taking away font smoothing and not using those variables anymore also maybe relates to the fact that maybe apple silicon was rushed a bit, and old software code needed to be replaced by new implementations, instead of going incremental way. But this is just a speculation. From marketing point of view having people this apple official dicussions forum post flagged almost 500 times is a big deal I think (https://discussions.apple.com/thread/254774275). This is top of a range device, and if apple has such a high amount of people complaining, then obviously it means they driffted away from extreme customer focus company closer to the Microsoft type of organisation, which as general purpose OS maker, can not please everyone as it is simply stread to thin in all the directions.
I have tested Ventura and Sequoia on macbook air m2 and I can see that Sequoia now defaults on my external moinitor BENQ PD2705Q to YcBcR 10bit color mode, rather than equivalent of RGB color mode. This is assuming betterDisplay does show it correctly. Also, it is hard to say, bet there might have been slight reduction in eye strain on Sequoia for external monitor use as well as built in panel (only setting - disable dithering on betterDisplay app, and color profile always sRGB, other settings defaults).
I take it back, it was because I was running USB 2.0, rather USB 3.1 interface. So it is no change here.
Another Interesting thing I have found - Sequoia (btw we I am not refering anymore to BETA, rather 15.2 version) now has much better non-integer scalling performance for the external monitor. E.g. for monitor BENQ PD2705Q which is native QHD/2k/WQHD monitor, running 1080p used to be very laggy as it was non integer scalling, but now 1080p runs super smooth. I was expecting 720p to be only option for performant scalled option on this monitor, but this is not a case anymore. So there is definitely something goinging in the backend.